Floor crossing… backroom deals… or a Canadian tradition?
Crossing the floor in parliament has always been a controversial topic in Canadian politics. It is interesting to now hear Conservatives describing recent floor crossings as illegitimate, a betrayal of voters, and dirty backroom deals.
During my time as a Conservative MP, 4 Liberal MPs crossed the floor to join the Conservatives: Liberal MPs David Emerson, Wajid Khan, Joe Comuzzi, and Leona Alleslev all made the journey across the floor from the Liberal benches to the Conservative side. At the time, Conservatives welcomed these Liberal floor crossers and described their decisions as principled.
When MPs were crossing in that direction, Conservative leaders explained that it was a parliamentary tradition in Canada. They also argued that MPs have the right to sit with whichever party best reflects their views. In defense of the practice, Conservative Leader Stephen Harper said that MPs sit as individuals, not bound to a party label.
Shortly after being elected as a Liberal, MP David Emerson was invited by Mr. Harper to cross the floor and join the Conservatives. He was immediately appointed to cabinet as the Conservative Minister of International Trade. This floor crossing was framed as being in the national interest, and therefore acceptable.
At the time, I publicly criticized David Emerson.not for crossing the floor itself, but for his past positions. He had repeatedly criticized the tariff exemption that the Maritime Lumber Bureau had negotiated with the United States. Atlantic Canadian lumber mills operated similarly to American mills, while other provinces were perceived to subsidize their mills. U.S. negotiators recognized this distinction and granted Atlantic Canada an exemption from softwood lumber tariffs. As a British Columbia Liberal MP, Mr. Emerson frequently opposed this arrangement.
For that reason, I did not support Mr. Emerson in any party.
Following my criticism, I was summoned to Prime Minister Harper s office. I arrived at the appointed time and entered the beautifully wood-paneled Prime Minister s office. Already present were Mr. Harper and the Conservative Whip Jay Hill. I noticed that Whip Jay Hill had a yellow file folder on his lap that appeared to be full. I didn t know what was in it, but it couldn t be good.
Mr. Harper was not behind his desk. Instead, he sat on the edge of a chair next to where I was to sit. Without any small talk, he began:
“You are publicly criticizing my appointment of David Emerson to cabinet.”
I replied, “No, I am not criticizing your appointment. I am criticizing David Emerson himself.but I have been doing that for years. I criticized him when he was president of Canfor, and later when he became a Liberal minister.”
I went on to explain that Mr. Emerson had consistently blamed Atlantic Canada for U.S. softwood lumber tariffs and opposed the Atlantic region s tariff exemption.
Mr. Harper responded, “Well, let’s just see about that.” Whip Jay Hill passed the yellow file folder to Mr. Harper. When he opened the file folder, I saw that it was chock full of press clippings. For several minutes, Mr. Harper silently reviewed each of my comments in the newspaper articles. Finally, he closed the folder and said:
“No you didn’t criticize my appointment… but you came awfully close.”
This was not the only time I was called to Mr. Harper’s office. I seemed to aggravate him quite often. I recount those meetings in detail in my upcoming book about my seven terms in office.
My point is this: during my time as a Conservative MP, the Conservative party frequently supported floor crossings, including that of Mr. Emerson. Today, they condemn the same practice as backroom deals, and worse.
I crossed the floor myself, although it was not my intention. It was because Mr. Harper expelled me from the Conservative caucus for voting against his changes to the Atlantic Accord. My seat was then moved from the front row on the government benches to the back row on the opposition side. I sat as an Independent MP for the remainder of that term.
Before the next election, Mr. Harper stated publicly on CBC television that I could not run again as a Conservative candidate. I then chose to run as an Independent candidate and won with 69 percent of the vote, without any party affiliation.
Mr. Harper could remove me from caucus, but thankfully he could not prevent me from seeking re-election as a Member of Parliament.
During my time as a Conservative MP, 4 Liberal MPs crossed the floor to join the Conservatives: Liberal MPs David Emerson, Wajid Khan, Joe Comuzzi, and Leona Alleslev all made the journey across the floor from the Liberal benches to the Conservative side. At the time, Conservatives welcomed these Liberal floor crossers and described their decisions as principled.
When MPs were crossing in that direction, Conservative leaders explained that it was a parliamentary tradition in Canada. They also argued that MPs have the right to sit with whichever party best reflects their views. In defense of the practice, Conservative Leader Stephen Harper said that MPs sit as individuals, not bound to a party label.
Shortly after being elected as a Liberal, MP David Emerson was invited by Mr. Harper to cross the floor and join the Conservatives. He was immediately appointed to cabinet as the Conservative Minister of International Trade. This floor crossing was framed as being in the national interest, and therefore acceptable.
At the time, I publicly criticized David Emerson.not for crossing the floor itself, but for his past positions. He had repeatedly criticized the tariff exemption that the Maritime Lumber Bureau had negotiated with the United States. Atlantic Canadian lumber mills operated similarly to American mills, while other provinces were perceived to subsidize their mills. U.S. negotiators recognized this distinction and granted Atlantic Canada an exemption from softwood lumber tariffs. As a British Columbia Liberal MP, Mr. Emerson frequently opposed this arrangement.
For that reason, I did not support Mr. Emerson in any party.
Following my criticism, I was summoned to Prime Minister Harper s office. I arrived at the appointed time and entered the beautifully wood-paneled Prime Minister s office. Already present were Mr. Harper and the Conservative Whip Jay Hill. I noticed that Whip Jay Hill had a yellow file folder on his lap that appeared to be full. I didn t know what was in it, but it couldn t be good.
Mr. Harper was not behind his desk. Instead, he sat on the edge of a chair next to where I was to sit. Without any small talk, he began:
“You are publicly criticizing my appointment of David Emerson to cabinet.”
I replied, “No, I am not criticizing your appointment. I am criticizing David Emerson himself.but I have been doing that for years. I criticized him when he was president of Canfor, and later when he became a Liberal minister.”
I went on to explain that Mr. Emerson had consistently blamed Atlantic Canada for U.S. softwood lumber tariffs and opposed the Atlantic region s tariff exemption.
Mr. Harper responded, “Well, let’s just see about that.” Whip Jay Hill passed the yellow file folder to Mr. Harper. When he opened the file folder, I saw that it was chock full of press clippings. For several minutes, Mr. Harper silently reviewed each of my comments in the newspaper articles. Finally, he closed the folder and said:
“No you didn’t criticize my appointment… but you came awfully close.”
This was not the only time I was called to Mr. Harper’s office. I seemed to aggravate him quite often. I recount those meetings in detail in my upcoming book about my seven terms in office.
My point is this: during my time as a Conservative MP, the Conservative party frequently supported floor crossings, including that of Mr. Emerson. Today, they condemn the same practice as backroom deals, and worse.
I crossed the floor myself, although it was not my intention. It was because Mr. Harper expelled me from the Conservative caucus for voting against his changes to the Atlantic Accord. My seat was then moved from the front row on the government benches to the back row on the opposition side. I sat as an Independent MP for the remainder of that term.
Before the next election, Mr. Harper stated publicly on CBC television that I could not run again as a Conservative candidate. I then chose to run as an Independent candidate and won with 69 percent of the vote, without any party affiliation.
Mr. Harper could remove me from caucus, but thankfully he could not prevent me from seeking re-election as a Member of Parliament.